- 1859 — Samuel J. Crop
- 1860 — James D. Perry
- 1861 — J. M. Clark
- 1862-1863 — Edgar Babcock
- 1864-1865 — J. M. Clark
- 1866-1868 — Alfred Bowen
- 1868-1872 — No record available
- 1872 — Henry C. Dent
- 1873 — John G. Perry, by June President and Trustees had resigned, S. W. Egbert finished the term.
- 1874 — S. S. Page
- 1875-1877 — A. H. Kinneas–citizens voted to reorganize village under general law
- 1877 — Issac Wikoff
- 1878 — A. H. Kinneas
- 1879 — George Painter
- 1880 — Dr. Z. H. Whitmore
- 1881-1882 — E. J. Avery
- 1883 — Garmen Gisk
- 1884 — Peter Schertz
- 1885 — James Graham
- 1886-1887 — E. J. Avery
- 1888-1890 — J. L. McGuire
- 1894 — President McGuire resigned, replaced by Henry Roberts
- 1895 — Henry Roberts
- 1896 — Ed B. Whitmire resigned, replaced by H. Weast
- 1897-1902 — J. C. Irving
- 1903-1904 — Frank Giehl
- 1905-1906 — J. C. Irving
- 1907-1910 — Frank Giehl
- 1911-1912 — J. I. Knoblauch
- 1913-1931 — John C. Snyder
- 1931-1945 — Robert J. Schneider
- 1945-1949 — Chris E. Wiedman
- 1949-1953 — Francis Kerrigan
- 1953-1957 — Chris E. Wiedman
- 1957-1961 — Francis Kerrigan
- 1961-1969 — Donald P. Smith
- 1969-1989 — Robert Harbers, Jr.
- 1989-1993 — Dale Whittington
- 1993-1998 — James B. Garber, died 10/24/97 while in office, John Bockler appointed Mayor Pro Tem
- 1998-2001 — Gene Hart
- 2001-2005 — Matthew O’Shea
- 2005-2009 — Paul Kouri
- 2009-2012 — William Belshaw, died 4/12/12 while in office, John Heinz appointed Mayor Pro Tem
History submitted by Shirley A. Adams.
